On iTunes 10: has Apple killed all its (good) UI designers?

So I just installed iTunes 10 and… wow. This isn’t a good ‘wow’. It’s just a… wow. Here’s why:

iTunes 10

Yup. Apple’s decided it’s been at least a few months since it screwed with the iTunes UI, and so it’s made some changes. Some of them actually work. There’s a decent ‘hybrid’ list view, and the main interface pane offers more clarity. However, two changes are mind-boggling:

  1. iTunes previously coloured its sidebar items. This enabled you to—without thinking—associate certain items with certain colours; even if you didn’t do this, each item was differentiated. Now, you have to think before you click, and the usability of this area of the app has been substantially reduced.
  2. The close/minimise/zoom buttons are now aligned vertically in the full window mode. In the mini-player window, this was always the case, but in the full window mode, it’s a baffling decision. Even though Mac OS X’s hardly a bastion of total consistency these days, these three important buttons usually stay put, and people’s muscle memory enables quick access to them. Now, iTunes 10 chucks Apple’s Human Interface Guidelines (the ones Apple seemingly expects every developer but itself to follow) out the window, in order to save a little horizontal space. However, this again reduces usability—not only are these buttons now in the wrong place, they’re also much smaller and harder to hit.

In the past, iTunes has foreshadowed subsequent updates to the look and feel of Mac OS X. I seriously hope that isn’t the case this time, because the iTunes 10 UI is a botch job—a collision of fairly good ideas (which are incremental updates) and the very worst in interface design. To that end, I wonder where all Apple’s best UI designers have gone. They’re certainly not on the iTunes team.

UPDATE: In the comments, mr_phillip writes: “For what it’s worth, defaults write com.apple.iTunes full-window -1 restores the default close/minimise buttons”. So at least Terminal-savvy Mac users have an option to deal with the second of Apple’s UI disasters.

Share this article:
  • Technorati
  • Reddit
  • Slashdot
  • Google Bookmarks
  • del.icio.us
  • Tumblr
  • LinkedIn
  • Digg
  • Facebook
  • Twitter

21 Comments

Posted: September 2, 2010

By Craig Grannell in Apple, Design, News, Opinions, Television

Apple’s Special Event: my thoughts, as written by someone else

Apple yesterday had another of its special events, which I noted would provide immediate disappointment with its open streaming that was only available to Snow Leopard-equipped Macs and iOS devices. (Good move, Apple! That’ll show Google and Adobe!)

As it turned out the event was, as usual, a mix of WOW, bleh, and eh? I was going to write a piece about it, but journo chum Adam Banks got there first and, spookily, his thoughts on what went on in San Fransisco yesterday mirror mine exactly. So, er, go and read Adam’s piece to see what I think about Apple’s announcements.

Share this article:
  • Technorati
  • Reddit
  • Slashdot
  • Google Bookmarks
  • del.icio.us
  • Tumblr
  • LinkedIn
  • Digg
  • Facebook
  • Twitter

No Comments

Posted: September 2, 2010

By Craig Grannell in Apple, News, Opinions, Technology

Apple to provide immediate disappointment for Mac and iOS users today

In a press release on its website, Apple has confirmed that it will “broadcast its September 1 event online”, thereby providing immediate disappointment to users worldwide when Jobs doesn’t reveal a $50 256GB unicorn-powered iPod touch with Retina Display and sprinkles.

The event will be streamed using “Apple’s industry-leading HTTP Live Streaming”, which the company says is “based on open standards, so fuck you, Adobe”. In order to view Apple’s open-standards streaming, you require a “Mac® running Safari® on Mac OS® X version 10.6 Snow Leopard®, an iPhone® or iPod touch® running iOS 3.0 or higher, or an iPad™”, along, presumably, with a shield to defend yourself from the onslaught of registered trademark characters, hypocrisy and irony.

Share this article:
  • Technorati
  • Reddit
  • Slashdot
  • Google Bookmarks
  • del.icio.us
  • Tumblr
  • LinkedIn
  • Digg
  • Facebook
  • Twitter

1 Comment

Posted: September 1, 2010

By Craig Grannell in Apple, Humour, News, Opinions, Television

About Revert to Saved

Revert to Saved is a blog written by me, Craig Grannell, a writer, designer and sometimes musician. You can often find my work in Retro Gamer, MacFormat, Computer Arts and .net

Follow me on Twitter via @CraigGrannell, @reverttosaved (RTS updates), and @iphonetiny (iPhone app reviews).

Work with me

If you’d like me to work with you on writing or design projects, contact me via the Snub Communications contact form, or email me directly at .

iPhoneTiny.com
The Essential Guide to CSS and HTML Web Design

Donate

If you like what you’ve read and fancy buying me virtual beer, click donate badge. For really generous types, there’s my Amazon wish-list.

Recent tweets

Follow me on Twitter @CraigGrannell

Recently on Revert to Saved

Recent comments