The ongoing battle for vestibular accessibility on iPhone, on Android and beyond

In 2013, I wrote a piece for The Guardian about iOS 7 causing motion sickness. This followed under-the-radar pieces about how animations could cause nausea and other symptoms in users. Fortunately, The Guardian piece got a lot of eyeballs on it, including – I was informed at the time – sufficiently senior people at Apple.

I remain deeply grateful to the iOS team in particular for subsequently taking vestibular accessibility seriously. The majority of issues I’ve flagged over the years have been acted upon. I vividly remember getting a wonderful surprise on the sole WWDC I was flown out to, on attending a developer session on accessibility and seeing someone on stage proudly noting that slide transitions in menus had been added to Reduce Motion. That was one of my last major issues on the platform, which I’d been bugging the iOS team about fixing. And, yes, reader, I may have welled up a bit.

But what I find disappointing is that, all these years after that Guardian piece broke, vestibular accessibility remains reactive rather than proactive. Nothing illustrates that better than Apple breaking Reduce Motion in Safari of all apps. When Reduce Motion is on, the zooms in the tab view should be replaced by crossfades. They were for a long time. But that went away in iOS 18. I dutifully mentioned this to Apple. It looks like this might be fixed in iOS 18.2. But the problem should never have come back in the first place – and it wouldn’t have if there was even the most rudimentary of testing by someone with Reduce Motion active.

Again, Apple’s iOS team has been the best of them, so I don’t want to slam its efforts. Other teams at Apple have been less responsive. And outside of Apple, my requests to help people with vestibular disorders have mostly been met with responses ranging from indifference to outright hostility. Fortunately, there are a few who do things right. I sent feedback to one major brand this year and received a call the very next day, asking how it could put things right. A month or so later, the app just worked. The animations had gone. But that’s rare. And it’s even rarer that this stuff is baked in from day one. It really shouldn’t be.

November 9, 2024. Read more in: Opinions, Technology

2 Comments

Weeknote: 2 November 2024: too many apps and not enough apps

(Image: Pixabay.)

Published stuff

This week’s column for Stuff: I don’t want more new tech gadgets where “there’s an app for that”. Enough with products solely reliant on an app to function.

For TapSmart, I wrote about accessories that transform your iPhone into a different gadget and an iPhone toolkit for better sleep.

Upcoming stuff

An article I’m very excited about is going live Monday afternoon UK time, apparently. I’ll be sharing on socials and also here in the next weeknote. (These days I’m mostly on Bluesky and Mastodon, with a smattering of Threads.)

Other stuff

Pixelmator got eaten by Apple. I’m thrilled for the team, but not so much for what this means for the company’s apps.

The Mac version of Pixelmator is an odd one. Although lauded by many on its debut, I gave it a hard time in the press, considering it to be clunky, resource-hungry and buggy. I suspect my initial reviews didn’t get me on the Christmas card list over at Pixelmator HQ. But over time, that Mac version improved and the mobile versions appeared. Today, Pixelmator for iPhone is a powerful mini-Photoshop of sorts, if one that’s barely ever updated. The company’s main app, Photomator, is a superb way to enhance your snaps, whatever your needs and skills.

It’s for the latter I suspect Apple bought the company. And time will tell whether this is a Dark Sky (buy; integrate some features; kill), Alchemy Synth (buy; add directly to another app) or a Logic Pro (buy; iterate; retain). If I had to guess, Pixelmator for iPhone is dead and Photomator features will be rolled into the edit interface of Apple’s Photos. But I’ll miss Pixelmator’s apps a lot. That’s something 2007 me would be very surprised to hear.

November 2, 2024. Read more in: Weeknotes

No Comments

Weeknote: 26 October 2024 – Apple devices, sunrise alarms and SAD

Published stuff

My column this week is: Now winter’s drawing in, the gadget I most care about is a sunrise alarm clock. I’ve known for years I have have a form of SAD, and that means mornings are tough when it’s dark when I get up. So this column is my love letter to niche tech that deserves no love. Because although it’s effective, it seems uniformly designed by people who don’t understand actual humans use technology. 

Other than that, it was a week of Apple. I reviewed the new iPad mini (“a mini update in almost every sense”) for Stuff, and over at TapSmart mulled that it went ‘Pro’ but not in the way I was hoping. (I also updated my iPad guide.)

For Stuff, I also checked out the iPhone 16 Plus (“The iPhone you’d pick last for your team”), while TapSmart got a round-up of 20 cracking single-purpose iPhone apps.

Other stuff

The clocks change this weekend. I hate it. Losing an hour of daylight makes me miserable. And while people will doubtless suggest I get an up hour earlier, then, the world doesn’t bend to my schedule. Lighter evenings are times for playing with my kid in the street, and enjoying the final warmth of the day. That’s all gone until April.

It’s always interesting around now to see how divisive changing the clocks is. In the US, I suspect many people forget how far south they are. By contrast, here in the north of Europe, not changing the clocks would either make for bizarre summers with sunrises at 3am, or very late sunrises in winter if we stuck with summer time all year. 

On the latter, that’s the main reason I’m unconvinced that the UK should change the clocks one spring and then never touch them again. It’d be rubbish for Scotland and that’s not fair. But that doesn’t mean I have to like the status quo either. Time to fire up the SAD lamp again…

October 26, 2024. Read more in: Weeknotes

No Comments

Weeknote: 19 October 2024 – retro games, app ecosystems and comics

Super Pockets

Published stuff

My column for Stuff this week is I’m converted: cheap and cheerful plug-and-play is a great way to revisit classic retro games. While I understand the love for original hardware and flexibility, I’m getting to the point where I just want to pick up a controller and play. Plug-and-play TV units do the job, but I’m also really enjoying the new Hyper Mega Tech Super Pockets, which are just play, rather than plug. 

Each one feels like a greatest hits album from a classic publisher. If you want to see the latest two in action, check out my 24-second YouTube first look ‘epic’.

Over at TapSmart, I wrote about iPhone 16 vs iPhone 16 Pro and asked whether the Pro is still worth it. And camera app Halide became the latest entry in my classic apps series.

Other stuff

Joan Westenberg asked people about the struggle between “the seamless simplicity of an all-Apple ecosystem [and] the freedom and flexibility of cross-platform independence”. I struggle with this myself. iCloud is too flaky to be reliable. Notes is a risk, because I for years had a scratchpad that had loads of stuff in, and it one day vanished. (I managed to get a version back by powering on a laptop I’d not opened in a week and turning off Wi-Fi before it could sync. That still lost me a week of input though.) Apps can help, such as Exporter, but I really wish Apple’s first-party apps were better at export. And that’s because I do value the simplicity of the ecosystem, and am now fully on board with the Reminders set-up I wrote about last week.

Elsewhere, I found myself in a discussion that comics are doomed because today’s children only love screens. Which is rubbish. What matters are habits, and those are driven by parents and accessibility.

Regarding comics, there are three issues. The first is that, for years (although this is changing), educators dismissed them. Children were taught comics were ‘lesser’ and not proper reading. I was therefore delighted when my daughter’s school specifically listed comics in her reading recommendations, alongside prose fiction, non-fiction, magazines and poetry. 

The second – arguably bigger – concern is we have an entire generation of parents who themselves never got into the comics habit in the UK, because the market was largely destroyed during the 1990s. I’m an old fart compared to many parents in my kid’s year. I also love comics. So mini-G has subs to three of them. As far as I’m aware, no-one else in her class is subscribed to any comics at all. One boy had (but no longer has) a Beano subscription. These kids are only ten years old. At that age, I had loads of the things.

Finally, there is the issue of accessibility. Comics used to be a working class thing and priced accordingly, but the market shifted. Magazines and comics are no longer impulse purchases like they once were, but things you consider. That in itself adds a barrier. Doubly so when you look at the rapid reduction in outlets as supermarkets pare back magazine sales and branches of WHSmith decide they want to focus on stationery and cards.

Fortunately, the market has responded. Bookstores sell chunky paperback comics and manga. Jamie Smart has sold over a million copies of Bunny vs Monkey. As a fan of that strip, I’m thrilled for Jamie Smart. But I can’t help but feel wistful for a time that gave kids more choice with cheap weeklies, which because of their sheer number gave many more cartoonists opportunities than comparatively risky books ever will.

If you’re in the UK, have a youngling and like the idea of comics, I strongly recommend the six issues for £1 offer from The PhoenixThe Beano and Monster Fun also have great offers for new subscribers as well.

October 19, 2024. Read more in: Weeknotes

No Comments

Weeknote: 12 October 2024 – alarm clocks, iPhones and Reminders

Alarmo from Nintendo

Published stuff

Nintendo has made an alarm clock. Which – if you’re old enough – shouldn’t come as a surprise. After all, Game & Watch units were also clocks. But I figured this was a good excuse over at Stuff to say: Forget Alarmo and Super Mario Clock – here are the 5 video game clocks the world really needs. This… may not be my most sensible column of the year. Fun to write though!

Also for Stuff, I reviewed the new iPhone Pro Max. Unsurprisingly, it’s a very good phone. But in a quietly impressive way. I don’t think there are going to be people throwing parties in the street over the new features. Speaking of which, over at TapSmart I got down my thoughts regarding two weeks with Camera Control. I mostly like it, but I’m not convinced, of all things, that the button is in the right place. 

And finally, I wrote up a guide on how to get started with Things.

Upcoming stuff

I filed a piece on iPhone gaming. This was a properly deep dive, involving some frankly absurd attempts to turn an iPhone into a Switch. I’m not sure when it’ll be published, but I’m looking forward to seeing that in the wild.

Elsewhere, I’m working on another of my classic apps pieces, about a long-time favourite – and an app that’s relevant to the new iPhones, let’s say.

Other stuff

I’m dreadful at bouncing between systems for organising my day. And the way things are for me of late (lots to do; time poor), I need to be better organised.

I used to add meetings in Calendar for approximate times articles would take to write. But as I moved into more corporate work and my schedule became rigid, that no longer worked. So I took to adding all-day events in Calendar for tasks, and used Widget Wizard to put the agenda on my Home Screens. This was twinned with a table in Notes that gave me an at-a-glance view of upcoming projects.

None of this was particularly flexible, and although I have dabbled with a range of GTD apps, I never settled on one. But inspired by Joan Westenberg’s piece on Apple stock apps, I took another look at Reminders. With its column view, you get something that’s like a basic kanban setup. I’ve got one board for freelance and another for a corporate client. Tags and deadlines give me alternate views across publications and times. The Today view tells me what I need to sort urgently.

The Apple solution is imperfect. Most notably, I’d love to have a ‘this week’ view, telling me what I need to sort before the weekend. I’ve faked that to some degree with a ‘next four days’ view, which somewhat works with my schedule. Still, it’s been interesting to use Reminders in this manner – and it really is helping.

Next up: sorting out Notes with something based on Forever * Notes.

October 12, 2024. Read more in: Weeknotes

No Comments

« older postsnewer posts »