Apple blocks Sony reader and common sense

The New York Times reports:

The company has told some applications developers, including Sony, that they can no longer sell content, like e-books, within their apps, or let customers have access to purchases they have made outside the App Store.

Apple rejected Sony’s iPhone application, which would have let people buy and read e-books bought from the Sony Reader Store.

This follows news that Apple is to block newspaper apps that enable people to view subscriptions for free through apps, and signals a shift in the way Apple deals with the App Store.

I’ve never had a major problem with the ‘closed’ nature of Apple’s store. Curation is a good thing, and despite the massive amount of crap on the App Store, the quality level certainly beats Android Market and its near-literal ‘anything goes’ model. But recent reports show Apple isn’t willing to give up its cut on anything it could potentially get a cut for.

The New York Times report is particularly worrying if it’s entirely accurate, in that it seems to suggest Apple will go further than it has before, blocking apps that enable access to any purchases made outside of the App Store. This would affect Amazon’s Kindle app and force users to use iBooks, which would hand millions of potential iOS users a damn good reason to seriously consider competing platforms.

My suspicion here is that the New York Times reporters don’t have a full understanding of the facts (and/or the underlying systems in the App Store), but question marks remain. After all, the Kindle system isn’t a million miles away from the newspaper subscription model that Apple is banning. However, I would hope that Apple isn’t going down that particular road, because making an enemy of Amazon (now the owner of Lovefilm, Apple’s biggest competition in digital music, and soon to open its own Android store) would be a bad move, and if Apple attempts to enforce its own systems and effectively ban the competition, it’s going to (rightly) get smacked hard by multiple anti-competition commissions and have the kind of PR fallout even Cupertino can’t dance around.

Update: ZDNet’s interpretation is along the same lines as the positive end of mine, thinking Sony submitted an app with IAPs, and that Kindle’s ‘buy through a browser’ model remains safe.

Update 2: Lex Friedman also thinks the NYT (via Sony) has its facts wrong. Lucky Apple PR’s there to answer our questions, eh?

Oh.

Update 3: Oh dear, Apple, what have you done?

February 1, 2011. Read more in: Apple, News, Opinions, Technology

Comments Off on Apple blocks Sony reader and common sense

Huge non-shock as Android tablets actually sell

DISASTER! SELL YOUR APPLE STOCK! Why? Because, according to Bloomberg and a billion other websites, Apple’s share of the tablet market has plummeted. During the three months to December 2010, Apple’s iPad grabbed ‘only’ 75 percent of shipments, down massively from the 95 percent it had in the previous quarter. Extrapolating wildly, analysts therefore predict Apple will within two years have a market share of minus 45 percent. ARGH!

Or, maybe—just maybe—what really happened is that Apple’s iPad had pretty much the entire market to itself at one point, and so got all the sales. And now there’s competition, Apple’s got less of the market. Of course, it’s a growing market, so Apple has a smaller slice of a much larger pie each quarter; also, it’s likely Apple’s profiting hand-over-fist and other companies aren’t, but SELL SELL SELL APPLE DOOMED OH MY GOD ANDROID FTW!

Oh, and  Neil Mawston, director at Strategy Analytics:

Even at $500 retail, based on some of the research we’ve done, that’s probably two or three times more than what most mass market consumers are expecting to pay.

Really? Well, I hope “most mass market consumers” will be happy with their $170 tablets that, clearly, won’t be total heaps of shit. (I know technology tends to drop in price over time, but $170 for a tablet? Really?)

January 31, 2011. Read more in: Apple, News, Opinions, Technology

4 Comments

On focus groups not telling you what’s best for them

A nice piece from MacRumors, which digs up a 1985 interview with Steve Jobs, including this gem of a quote:

My philosophy is that everything starts with a great product. So, you know, I obviously believed in listening to customers, but customers can’t tell you about the next breakthrough that’s going to happen next year that’s going to change the whole industry. So you have to listen very carefully. But then you have to go and sort of stow away—you have to go hide away with people that really understand the technology, but also really care about the customers, and dream up this next breakthrough.

This is a problem with many industries, not least the majority of the tech world. Most companies provide customers with what they say they want; good companies provided customers with what they actually need, even when they didn’t realise they needed it.

January 25, 2011. Read more in: Apple, Opinions, Technology

Comments Off on On focus groups not telling you what’s best for them

Tim Cook isn’t Steve Ballmer

Paul Thurrott:

There are some parallels to draw between […] Cook’s taking over day-to-day operations at Apple […] and Steve Ballmer’s ascension at Microsoft. And not to ruin the surprise, but this may be bad news for Apple. The simplest way to explain this is to simply provide the closing quote in the [NY Times] article: “He will not be the visionary, but that’s O.K. because there are other talented people around him.” Sure. That’s what they said about Ballmer too. Just a thought.

John Gruber:

There are some parallels: an operations executive succeeding a visionary product-oriented founder. But, I’d say Cook-as-Ballmer is pretty much the worst case scenario for Apple.

The warnings signs with Ballmer have been there for years. He’s been out of touch for a long time. Remember when he laughed at the iPhone? Said it had “no chance”? Let’s not worry about Tim Cook until he starts saying dumb things.

In addition to that, I’m pretty sure Tim Cook’s never leapt about the stage like a mental person. He also led Apple through the previous period where Jobs was away from the action, and hasn’t put a foot wrong when he’s been under the spotlight at Apple events or on earnings calls.

Even in the most recent earnings call, Cook differentiated himself from Ballmer in dismissing the opposition. Ballmer got caught by claiming Apple’s product had no chance, yet it went on to be a massive success. Cook’s dismissal of Android tablets is based on facts rather than guesswork. On Honeycomb tablets (i.e. the first Android tablets with an OS actually designed for tablets rather than smartphones), he states:

There’s nothing shipping yet, so I don’t know. They lack performance specs, they lack prices, they lack timing. Today, they’re vapour. We’ll assess them as they come out. However, we’re not sitting still…

There’s a big difference there from “no chance”.

January 25, 2011. Read more in: Apple, Opinions, Technology

Comments Off on Tim Cook isn’t Steve Ballmer

Entitlement in the music industry and The Pirate Bay being dicks

Trying to annoy the music industry for the billionth time, The Pirate Bay says its next major launch will be fear.themusicbay.org, according to TechRadar. An unnamed insider is quoted as follows:

The music industry can’t even imagine what we’re planning to roll out in the coming months.

For years they’ve complained bitterly about piracy, but if they ever had a reason to be scared it is now.

Roughly translated: LOOK AT THE SIZE OF OUR HUGE PENIS!

Yeah, well done, The Pirate Bay. You celebrate ‘sticking it to the man’, including the artists (who clearly don’t deserve anything for their work) and those evil indie labels (who burn millions per second with their unicorn-powered cocaine factories).

The majors need a slap, certainly, but the battle’s largely been won in music: DRM-free track-by-track sales across many sites, direct-selling from indies, and the likes of Spotify for on-demand access to as much music as you can consume. I’m not sure how the Pirate Bay’s antics will improve things; instead, they’re more likely to enforce to many the feeling that they should, for some reason, be entitled to free music and that everyone they rip off somehow had it coming.

January 24, 2011. Read more in: Music, Opinions, Technology

2 Comments

« older postsnewer posts »