Google chrome—the ‘best of’ browser
You get the feeling someone’s spoiling for a fight in the browser race. Compared to the late-1990s pissing match between Microsoft’s Internet Explorer and Netscape Navigator, we’re now in a period of relative stability, and once Microsoft finally wheels IE 8 coughing and spluttering into the daylight, designers and developers will be able to code pretty much without hacks across all current browsers.
Bar Microsoft, what remains of the browser race is all about innovation, but as the Redmond giant has shown, ‘innovation’ can also mean waiting to see what others do and copying them. With Internet Explorer 7, Microsoft got all excited about ‘innovative’ features like tabs, which had been irrevocably welded to practically every other browser for years. And with Google essentially being the new Microsoft, should it have come as any surprise to see its upcoming browser project, the badly-named Chrome, pushing the innovation angle hard, and yet pilfering as much as possible from other browsers before anyone really notices?
At the time of writing, Google Chrome has yet to be revealed, bar the press release and a rather odd comic book. (Expect to see that adapted into a Hollywood movie starring Shia LaBeouf by November.) However, we can glean the following:
- It’s based on WebKit (like Safari)
- The so-called ‘special tabs’ are above the window (like Opera’s)
- It offers thumbnails of recently visited websites (kinda like Opera’s Speed Dial)
- It has a privacy mode (like Safari)
- It has intelligent address bar auto-complete (like Opera and, to some extent, Firefox)
- It has malware protection (like Firefox)
… And so on. In fact, bar its ability to launch web apps in standalone browser windows without browser junk, I failed to see a single piece of major innovation. (And even that idea isn’t really new—Prism and Fluid are single-site browsers. Chrome’s only addition is in making it easier to launch SSBs from the main browser itself, and then protecting them by ensuring all instances are separate processes.)
I should be livid about Chrome, shouting from rooftops and damning it to places where things are damned. Google is doing the thing I hate most: it’s a massive company, nicking other people’s ideas and smushing them together into a big ol’ sticky ball of best-of goo.
The thing is, having recently reviewed every major Mac browser for a Mac magazine and most PC ones for a Windows publication, it appears Chrome is exactly what I’ve been asking for. It’s picking the best bits, potentially killing that nagging feeling that you get when using one browser’s great feature and just wishing it had that other feature from that other browser. Whether that’ll be enough for me to get over that feeling of utter wrongness at seeing everyone else’s ideas compiled into the browser equivalent of a Now That’s What I Call Music compilation, only time will tell.

It sure would, comic-book man. But why bother when you can steal everyone else’s ideas?
I wonder where this leaves Googles relationship with Firefox and whether this will pan out to be more of a threat to Mozilla or Microsoft. At least it’s built on a decent platform (webkit) so perhaps we might see members of the general public adopting a browser with decent standards compliance! If anyone can give us a standards based browser with a dominant market share it’s Google.
I suspect Google will cunningly retain its relationship with Mozilla for now. If Chrome doesn’t take off, it still has lots of hits coming in from Firefox. If Chrome is a success, it can ditch Mozilla at its leisure.
My excellent chum, I dislike your layout.
Also: They quite rightly say “we stoled stuff”, they just don’t say which bits came from where 🙂
[…] week ago, I posted my thoughts on Google Chrome, based on Google’s press release and comic book. This got me my fastest-ever flame, in just ten […]
i think google will maintain relations with mozilla but this will give them more bargaining power to request mozilla work better with google apps, mail and other web tools.