Alex Levinson on the truth behind Apple’s iPhone tracking and collecting data
A wave of paranoia has been unleashed by discoveries that your iPhone is tracking your every move (Guardian), prompting some to assume Apple is sending the data to the mothership, in order to have you beaten to death if you don’t look at enough iAds every month. MAN, THOSE APPLE GUYS ARE EVIL.
But wait!
Alex Levinson reports some shocking discoveries:
- Apple is not collecting the data;
- The location data is used by software such as Maps and Camera, in order to operate;
- The hidden file is neither new nor secret (it’s just moved);
- The ‘discovery’ was in fact published in 2010.
But hang on… If this is all the case, then this is the media whipping up a bullshit frenzy about Apple, just because that’s more newsworthy than:
Location data still on Apple device, so location-oriented apps still work. Bloke writes app to pull data to desktop. World doesn’t explode. No-one really cares. Well, apart from editors who know they can fire up the link-bait machine. Oh, and people going ARGH, THEY KNOW WHERE I’VE BEEN while tweeting their geo-location data, checking into Foursquare and Gowalla and posting to Facebook that they’re “away from home, in a pub on the Thames, if you want to join me,” which of course has NO SECURITY IMPLICATIONS WHATSOEVER.
Oh.
And it was in the terms and conditions that Apple “may” use data on where, when and what you are using your iPhone on/for… read them carefully.
I’m glad that you don’t care that your phone (and your Mac) both contain a list of where you’ve been in the last year. Personally, I’d rather not do that (and no, I also don’t use Gowalla, Foursquare, or any other location-based social network).
Are you telling me that I’m not allowed to be pissed off that Apple did this, without even telling me about it? That I shouldn’t at least have the option to turn it off?
By all means be pissed off, but the locations are vague, anonymous and used to improve location-based services. More to the point, it’s not like this is new to mobile phones. The difference here is that the file is now somewhat easier to access than before.
Still, if Gruber’s right, expect this to be squished in the next point release of iOS anyway—he reckons it’s a bug (not the collection/data-sending, but its retention).
The fact that it’s easier to access than before (i.e., it’s stored on your own system, rather than stored at some telco) can be a pretty big difference, depending on your local jurisdiction.
Also, how is it used to improve location-based services? Like you yourself say, it’s probably a bug, not an intentional feature. It’s most likely not used for anything.
Word failure—should have been implement rather than improve. Blame deadline fatigue/surprising April sun in the UK.
Probably too late to tell you to enjoy the weather 🙂
[…] Alex Levinson on the truth behind Apple’s iPhone tracking and collecting data […]
interesting in this case
http://www.macworld.com/article/159528/2011/04/how_iphone_location_works.html
Mm. Finally, the word’s getting out: Apple doesn’t know where you are, and while the data on your phone does to some extent (at least in terms of locale, but not house address), that isn’t really an issue for the vast, vast, vast majority.