Good grief, The Guardian. Last week, you reported:
Doctor Who has faced many fearsome foes in the past, but none of them have been a Bolton-born TV presenter who yells “Our survey says”.
This was on the back of the show’s plummeting audience share, which saw it beaten by All Star Family Fortunes, to which The Guardian suggested:
The current series of Doctor Who – the second overseen by showrunner Steven Moffat – has faced criticism that it is too scary and too complicated for younger fans.
To be fair, The Guardian isn’t alone. Lots of publications are saying Doctor Who is screwed, largely because Moffat has the audacity to create plots that make you think a bit, that hold up brilliantly to rewatching (so you can figure out what you missed), and that have an intelligence and horror that was largely lacking in the (still pretty good) Russell T Davies era.
Only it’s not quite that simple. Tom Spilsbury reports that ratings are far more complicated than they used to be, and Who performs extremely well on the BBC Three repeat, recordings and iPlayer. The linked post shows that the current series is up on the first three series, and down only slightly on the 2008 run. Spilsbury says the following on this (WARNING: CONTAINS SPOILERS FOR SERIES FOUR):
This can partially be put down to the final half of the series which concluded with Journey’s End, the return of Rose, the return of Davros, the fake regeneration, etc. Journey’s End was the top rated show of the week, and amassed almost 15 million viewers across all outlets, so this really gave a boost to the series average.
So what does The Guardian run with this week? Doctor Who’s mixed fortunes continue, which at least notes that the statistical reversal of All Star Family Fortunes ‘winning’ the ratings war again will be “shortlived”. So, not really mixed fortunes at all then, unless you consider it to be ‘mixed fortunes’ when your favourite football team goes to half-time a goal down, but then ends up winning two-one.
September 26, 2011. Read more in: News, Opinions, Television
Spotify is seriously Facebook-friendly, says the service on its website. But it’s one thing being friendly and another being assimilated. So it’s with more than a little sadness that I read this thread on Get Satisfaction. Baffled user Dean asks:
There seems to be nowhere on Spotify’s website that lets you sign up for Spotify without a Facebook account. The sign up links ask to to log in to Facebook or create a new Facebook account.
Is there a hidden link anywhere on the website that lets you sign up without linking it to a Facebook account?
Clearly, Dean must be some kind of numpty, because, surely, Spofity wouldn’t be so insanely stupid to require you to have a Facebook account to sign-up, right? Right? Luckily, ’employee’ Darran was on hand to put everyone’s minds to rest. And by ‘put everyone’s minds to rest’, I mean ‘punch you all in the face if you had any idealistic thoughts about Spotify being anything other than Facebook’s bitch these days’:
Unfortunately you will need a Facebook account to access Spotify from now on, unless you already have an account set up.
This does not stop you creating the Facebook account adding nothing to it and making it totally private as the Facebook account does not have to be actively used.
This is a mind-bafflingly stupid decision. The only thought that crossed my mind is that Spotify is in a financial mess and needed a Facebook injection, but Facebook said “I will only inject money goodness into you, if you’re shackled to me forever”. Because Zuckerberg is kinky that way.
September 26, 2011. Read more in: News, Opinions, Technology
Matt Gemmell, writing SEO for Non-dicks:
I’m asked sometimes for advice on building an internet presence, and I usually have to fumble for an answer – because I haven’t pursued any particular strategy beyond the glaringly obvious: create original, relevant content repeatedly.
He’s right, of course, but it’s not quite that easy. The stats in Gemmell’s post that he says aren’t massive nonetheless dwarf those I get, and, from what I hear, my stats are larger than some people I know who are writing great stuff. I’d argue the same sort of effect we see in the App Store is just as rampant on the internet in general, in that big brands (and people can be brands in this context) get lodged in people’s heads, regardless of whether they’re writing great content or utter bollocks. It’s also well known that sites that update more often get more hits, even if the content is churn-based tat that you can read on a million other sites. Now and again, you get a ‘breakout indie’, which is where I’d place Gemmell—smart, intelligent writing that bucks the trend of ‘churnalism’ that’s depressingly common these days.
The thing is, content is all that should matter for most writers at the personal level, unless they’re naïve enough to think their blog is the road to riches. Revert to Saved bumbled about in various forms for a bit, before settling in its current incarnation—largely tech-oriented bitching from a largely tech-oriented writer. It was never meant to be anything massive, although I am hugely grateful when people read my stuff and it sparks discussion, either online on other blogs, or directly with me in the comments or on Twitter. And then there is always that possibility that audience and traffic will grow, The Deck will come knocking and you’ll be able to make something of a living off of your own project’s writing, rather than solely writing for others.
Of course, traffic tends to only grow if you’re a dick (write often, rip-off others, use dodgy SEO) or a talented non-dick who perhaps gets a bit lucky (or makes their own luck). I’d certainly rather be the latter than the former.
September 22, 2011. Read more in: Opinions, Writing
Mary-Jo Foley at ZDNet argues that the Windows 8 interface will be consistent across all devices, partly contradicting what I wrote yesterday about the system (in that on a tablet Windows 8 would be closer to iOS in concept than Windows).
Given that we’re a year away from Windows 8’s release and Microsoft’s being quite contradictory about it, I’d say there’s a lot of time for things to be nailed down. I suspect there is also an internal struggle at Microsoft. I’ll bet there are certain people within Microsoft arguing hard for retaining ‘proper’ Windows on tablets, because “that’s what people want”, and others arguing to ditch it, because “that’s what people need”. Alternatively, perhaps we’ll end up in a situation where the Desktop ‘app’ that boots the ‘classic’ Windows experience exists on tablets, but is all but irrelevant, due a lack of app support and the interface not being suitable for touch. That wouldn’t be great, but assuming there are plenty of Metro-style apps, that wouldn’t hugely affect performance nor the experience of using a Windows 8 tablet.
September 20, 2011. Read more in: News, Opinions, Technology
Tsk, eh? Those pesky, uncooperative (if you’re a tech pundit) markets are really screwing things up. Last week, we got the news that in the face of myriad iPad killers, the iPad’s share had PLUMMETED. No, wait. Electronista reported IDC’s data as stating that
the iPad had gained share, moving up from 65.7 percent at the start of the year to 68.3 percent.
But surely all those wonderful Android tablets with loads of ports and Flash and not-at-all-iPad-like shells are selling fast, right?
Multiple Android tablets’ arrivals only led to Google’s share shrinking, dropping from 34 percent in early 2011 to 26.8 percent mid-year.
Oh.
Still, I’m sure that won’t stop plenty of people banging on about how the iPad is doomed at some point in 2011, or 2012, or definitely by 2013. 2014 at the latest. Or maybe 2015. Just like Apple itself, really. Now Steve Jobs is no longer CEO, the company’s pretty much screwed, as evidenced by the hard-hitting article in the New York Times, Without Jobs, Apple Shares Hit All-Time High:
At the end of regular trading Monday, Apple shares closed at $411.63, up 2.78 percent, with a new record-high market valuation of $381.62 billion. It is now clearly the most valuable company on the stock market, displacing Exxon Mobil, with a market capitalization of $358.34 billion.
Ah. Still, give it a week or two and I’m sure we’ll have analysts and pundits falling over themselves to argue that this time, the new iPhone won’t sell, because of all the great alternatives out there. Just wait and see!
September 20, 2011. Read more in: Apple, News, Opinions, Technology